The Etihad Stadium, home of Manchester City, from the air
The Etihad Stadium, Manchester. Photo: Arne Müseler, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE, via Wikimedia Commons
Premier League logo
PREMIER LEAGUE
v
Manchester City crest
MANCHESTER CITY

Manchester City broke Premier League financial rules for nine seasons, an independent Commission has ruled. In a decision published on 29 September 2026, it found every charge of serious financial breaches proven — and all but one part of the charge of failing to co-operate — after concluding that more than £830 million booked as sponsorship income was in fact paid by a company of the club's owner. No punishment has been set yet, and City lodged their appeal on 1 October.

Where it all started

The story began with a leak, not a lawsuit.

  • November 2018: the German magazine Der Spiegel starts publishing leaked Manchester City emails (the "Football Leaks" files). The Premier League opens its own investigation the following month.
  • February 2020: UEFA finds City overstated sponsorship revenue in accounts submitted between 2012 and 2016. The punishment: a two-season ban from European competition and a €30m fine.
  • July 2020: the Court of Arbitration for Sport lifts the ban and cuts the fine to €10m. Most of UEFA's case was "either not established or time-barred" — UEFA's rules only look back five years — and City were punished only for failing to co-operate.

The Premier League's rulebook has no such five-year limit, which is why its own case could reach back to 2009.

What City were charged with

On 6 February 2023 the Premier League referred the case to an independent Commission. The league never published a single total — "115 charges" is the count the media settled on. The charges fall into five groups:

ChargeSeasonsVerdict
Accurate financial information — sponsorship, costs, related parties2009/10–2017/18Proven
Full details of manager and player pay2009/10–2015/16Proven
UEFA licensing and Financial Fair Play rules2013/14–2017/18Proven
Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules2015/16–2017/18Proven
Co-operating with the investigationDecember 2018 onwardsProven, except part 4(B)

The hearing

The case was heard in private in London from 16 September to 6 December 2024: 42 hearing days, witness statements from six people for the league and 24 for the club, and around 7,000 pages of transcripts. Then came almost two years of waiting for the verdict.

What the Commission found

The Premier League published a redacted, 40-page "core decision" on 29 September 2026. Its main findings:

  • Sponsorship: over nine seasons City's accounts recorded £949.94 million of sponsorship from Abu Dhabi companies. Those sponsors paid £119.25 million themselves; the other £830.69 million was paid by ADUG, the owner's company. The decision says income was "hugely overstated by over £830 million".
  • Hidden pay: three separate arrangements paid people through the owner's money rather than the club's books. The individuals are redacted in the published decision.
  • Image rights: a separate arrangement overstated income by £24.5 million and understated costs by more than £49 million.
  • Spending rules: City failed UEFA's break-even requirement "by a very substantial amount" in every relevant season, and failed the Premier League's profitability limit — a maximum loss of £105 million over three years — from 2015/16 to 2017/18.
  • Co-operation: the Commission found the club "made concerted efforts to stop and frustrate the PL investigation". One part of that charge, 4(B), was not proven.

The Commission said the club "clearly intended to circumvent the PL Rules", and concluded that some of City's witnesses gave evidence they knew "to be untrue". Taking revenue and costs together, the Premier League puts the total at "more than £900 million".

Masters called it the core of the case: the decision "details how the club systematically broke Premier League Rules for nearly a decade."

What Manchester City say

City say they are "disappointed and surprised" by the verdict and remain "innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League". The club says the decision "contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe", that "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions", and that it will be "relentless" in "any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums". Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak told supporters in a letter on 26 September that his confidence in proving the club's innocence was unchanged.

What happens next

Three questions are still open:

  • The appeal — now lodged. City lodged what they call a "comprehensive" appeal at 7pm on Thursday 1 October 2026, a day before the deadline, saying the decision is "unsafe" and that the club is "innocent of the accusations". An Appeal Board of three, chaired by someone who has held judicial office, reviews the decision in private — it is a review, not a retrial. Under the league's rules the hearing should take place within 12 weeks (by the week before Christmas) and last no more than five days, and the board then has 30 days to rule — which points to a decision around the third week of January 2027. It can dismiss the appeal, allow it, send the case back to the Commission or change the decision. Reports say City may argue the faster timetable does not apply to their case, which could push it later into 2027. The league says the hearing "will remain private and confidential until publication of the outcome is permitted".
  • The punishment. In the league's words, "the issue of sanction will be addressed separately in a further hearing with the independent Commission". No date has been set, and it is not yet clear whether it will come before or after the appeal. The rules carry no fixed tariff, so the Commission has wide powers; reports list fines and points deductions among the options.
  • Other clubs. Arsenal, Liverpool, Manchester United and Tottenham reportedly served notices in November 2024 reserving the right to claim compensation. None of that has been tested.

A separate fight that is already over

Alongside the charges, City went to court in 2024 over the league's rules on deals with companies linked to a club's owner (Associated Party Transactions). A tribunal upheld most of the system in October 2024 but found parts of it unlawful; the rules were amended; and on 8 September 2025 the two sides settled, with City accepting the current rules as "valid and binding". That dispute is closed and is separate from this verdict.

What it means on the pitch

Right now, nothing changes. Manchester City — managed by Enzo Maresca since Pep Guardiola left in the summer — top the Premier League going into the international break, and Erling Haaland leads the scoring chart with five goals in five games.

PosTeamPts
1Manchester City15
2Arsenal12
3Brighton10

The table only moves if the Commission hands down a points deduction, and that can only come after the sanction hearing.

Enzo Maresca
Enzo Maresca
Manchester City manager since summer 2026
Erling Haaland
Erling Haaland
Premier League top scorer — 5 goals in 5 games

Timeline

DateWhat happened
Nov 2018Leaked City emails published; the Premier League opens its investigation
Feb 2020UEFA bans City from Europe for two seasons and fines them €30m
Jul 2020CAS lifts the ban and cuts the fine to €10m
6 Feb 2023The Premier League refers the charges to an independent Commission
Sep–Dec 202442-day hearing in London
8 Sep 2025City and the league settle the separate APT dispute
29 Sep 2026Decision published: charges proven, except part 4(B)
1 Oct 2026City lodge their appeal, a day before the deadline
By late Dec 2026Appeal hearing due (within 12 weeks)
Jan 2027Appeal decision expected (within 30 days of the hearing)

When the Premier League returns after the international break, every Pundit Kings prediction is published before kick-off and every result stays on the public record — see today's board at [punditkings.com](/).

Sources: the independent Commission's published decision and the Premier League statement of 29 September 2026; Manchester City's statements of 29 September and 1 October 2026; the Premier League statement on the appeal (1–2 October 2026); Sky Sports, ESPN and Al Jazeera reporting on the appeal timetable (2–3 October 2026); UEFA and CAS statements (2020).
Cover photo: the Etihad Stadium, Manchester — Arne Müseler / www.arne-mueseler.com (cropped by Blackcat), CC BY-SA 3.0 DE, via Wikimedia Commons.